Nov
17
2026
The promoted biller
Most recruitment managers were never trained to manage. They were trained to bill. They billed very well, and one day somebody handed them a team as a thank you.
It’s the most common promotion in our industry. It’s also one of the most expensive mistakes we make, and we keep making it for perfectly good reasons.
Why we do it
Let’s be fair to the owners who do this. Most of us have done it, or had it done to us. It certainly happened to me.
The top biller has earned something. They’re ambitious, and if you don’t offer them a next step, a competitor will. They know the desk inside out. The team respects them, because nothing earns respect on a sales floor like the biggest number on the board. And, quite often, there is simply nobody else.
So the logic holds. Promote the best, and the best will make others like them.
Except selling and managing are different jobs.
Somebody went and checked
In 2019 three economists, Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue, published a study of promotions in sales organisations. They called it “Promotions and the Peter Principle”, after Laurence Peter’s old joke that people get promoted until they reach a job they can’t do.
Put simply, they found what most of us suspected. Firms promoted their best sellers into management. The best sellers were, on average, not the best managers, and their teams felt it. The firms were promoting on the skill people already had, not the skill the new job needed. The study is getting old now, but nothing has changed.
Nobody who has spent time on a recruitment floor will be shocked. It’s still useful to have it in writing.
What changes on day one
Yesterday your best consultant was measured on what they did. Today they’re measured on what other people do.
That is a bigger shift than it sounds, because the habits that made them a great biller start working slightly against them.
They’re fast. So when a junior fumbles a call, they take the phone. The deal closes, and the junior learns that the manager will always step in.
They’re competitive. So the Monday meeting becomes a leaderboard, and the people at the bottom of it go quiet.
They’re used to being right. So one-to-ones turn into instructions, and nobody brings them a problem until it’s too late to fix.
And they still love the desk. So they keep their own billings going, and the management happens in whatever time is left over. Which is none.
None of that is bad intent. It’s a good consultant doing what has always worked for them.
Understandable. It’s also how good teams stall.
The cost turns up later
The damage rarely shows in the first quarter. The new manager’s own billings often hold the numbers up, so the board looks fine.
It shows later. In the consultant who leaves before they ever got going. In the desk that never grows beyond the person running it. And in the promoted biller who, some time later, goes back to a desk or out of the door, because the job made them miserable and nobody noticed until the resignation letter.
You can lose your best biller and a decent team in one move.
What good owners actually do
They separate progression from management. Ask your best biller if they want to progress and they’ll say yes. Ask if they want to manage and you may get a different answer. A proper senior billing route, with a title, a bigger desk and real recognition, keeps people doing what they’re brilliant at. It also means the people who do manage chose to.
They train before the promotion, not after the first resignation. Running a one-to-one, giving hard feedback, chairing a Monday meeting people don’t dread: very few of us are born able to do these. They’re skills, and skills can be taught and practised.
They change what the manager is paid for. If a new manager’s bonus still rests mostly on their own billings, you’ve told them exactly where to spend their time. Measure the team, and say so on day one.
They give the new manager someone to talk to. Not a book and not a course on its own. A person, outside the team, who they can ring after a one-to-one that went badly.
They give them leadership training. They teach them.
None of this is complicated. It just has to happen before the promotion, rather than as a rescue.
Something to try this week
Think about the last person you promoted from the desk.
What did you teach them to do before they started? What are they actually paid for: their own billings, or their team’s? Who do they call when a conversation with one of their people goes wrong?
And, more personally: when you were first given a team, who taught you how to manage it?
Sources
– Alan Benson, Danielle Li and Kelly Shue, “Promotions and the Peter Principle”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019 (landmark study, cited for the idea, not as current data).
– Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull, The Peter Principle, 1969 (book).
