You get the call. A business you have wanted for two years is reviewing its recruitment suppliers, and they would like to meet three agencies next Thursday. You are one of them.
You block out the afternoon. You pull together the credentials deck, the one with the logos and the placement figures. You rehearse the bit about your market knowledge. On Thursday you arrive early, shake hands and give it everything.
Two weeks later, you hear they have gone with someone else. The feedback, if you get any, is polite and vague. “It was very close.”
It usually wasn’t.
Most pitches are not lost in the room. They are lost in the days before it, in the small things the client noticed while you were busy polishing the deck.
What the client saw before you arrived
Think about what that hiring manager actually experienced of you before Thursday. A confirmation email. Perhaps a calendar invite. That’s it.
Now think about the agency that won. Chances are they rang before the meeting. Not to pitch, but to ask. Who else will be in the room? What went wrong with the last supplier? What would a good outcome look like a year from now? They may have looked at the careers page, noticed the roles that had been open since the summer, and asked about those.
By the time the meeting started, the client had already had a better conversation with them than they were about to have with you.
That isn’t a presentation skill. It’s preparation, and the client can see it.
Why we skip it
I understand why it happens. You are busy. You have live roles, candidates to manage and a manager asking about your numbers. A call to ask questions before a meeting feels like an extra step when you already have the meeting.
And there’s a less comfortable reason. Asking in advance means hearing things you might not like. That they are fed up with agencies in general. That the budget is smaller than you hoped. That they have a preferred supplier and are meeting you to keep them honest.
That explains it. It doesn’t excuse it.
Every one of those answers changes what you should say on Thursday. You are far better off knowing on Monday.
What it costs you
Walk in unprepared and you spend most of the first half talking about yourself, because you don’t know enough about them to talk about anything else. The client sits through your credentials, waiting for the bit that is about their problem. It never quite arrives.
They don’t think you are bad. They just think you are the same as everyone else. And the same as everyone else doesn’t win a supplier review. At best, you make the list. At worst, you were the agency invited to make the other two look good.
What good recruiters actually do
They treat the pitch as starting the moment the meeting is booked.
They ring beforehand with three or four questions, and they say why: “So I don’t waste your time on Thursday.” Nobody has ever been offended by that.
They find out who will be in the room and what each person cares about. The HR lead and the hiring manager rarely want the same thing.
They open the meeting by playing back what they heard. “When we spoke, you mentioned…” It takes a moment, and it tells the client you were listening before you were selling.
And they leave the credentials deck until the end, if they use it at all.
Something to try this week
Look at the next pitch or client meeting in your diary. Before you touch the deck, write down the things you don’t yet know about that client that would change what you say. Then pick up the phone and ask.
If they won’t take a short call before the meeting, that tells you something too.
So here’s the question to sit with. In the last pitch that didn’t go your way, how much did you really know about the client’s problem before you walked in?